China
Volts Don’t Lie? An Alternative Approach to Calculating China’s Growth
By Tom Orlik China’s Vice Premier Li Keqiang said in 2007 that the GDP data for the world’s second largest economy was ‘man made’ and not to be trusted. Instead, the then Party Secretary of Liaoning Province said, he relied on electricity production, train freight and bank loan data as a guide to the state of the economy. Last month, CRT looked at the strengths and weaknesses of China’s GDP data, concluding that the government’s methods for calculating the size of the world’s second-largest economy had improved but still left something to be desired . Are electricity statistics a better guide to growth? Electricity output has a special place in the world of China’s economic data. Officials might lie, it is believed, but volts do not. Ever since economists cried foul on the 1998 GDP data, citing the difference between falling growth in production of electricity and stable growth in GDP, the markets have viewed the electricity data as a proxy for overall growth. That makes some sense. The manufacturing and industrial sectors are major consumers of electricity; changes in output should be reflected in changes in electricity production. Over the last several years, growth in electricity output has moved more or less in line with growth in industrial output. With some of China’s main growth indicators putting in a dismal performance in the last few months, and concerns about a hard landing for the economy, the electricity data provides an optimistic counterpoint. Following a weak April and May, electricity output was up 16.2% year-on-year in June, suggesting a strengthening economy. That contrasts with a weak reading from the preliminary HSBC PMI report in July, which suggested contraction is on the cards. But before breaking out the celebratory baijiu and heading out for karaoke, China’s economic policy makers should consider a few shortcomings of the electricity output data as a guide to growth: – Changes in the structure of the economy change the relationship between growth and electricity consumption. For example, a shrinking role for manufacturing and a larger role for services – something China’s economic planners have been pushing lately — reduces growth in electricity production but not necessarily growth in GDP. And even with no change in the structure of industry, many manufacturers have off-grid generators that they can switch on or off without affecting electricity production data – which only captures on-grid activity. – China’s electricity producers have their own problems. Hydropower accounts for 16% of China’s electricity output. Droughts in April and May meant generators ran into difficulties. Heavy rain has now brought them whirring back to life. Neither the drought nor the flood said much about the underlying strength of demand for electricity. Changes in costs for coal – the main input into electricity generation – can also play havoc with production. – Households account for 12% of electricity consumption and their demand is affected mainly by the weather – which determines whether central heating and air conditioners are on or off – with little relation to changes in growth. All of these factors mean the relation between electricity production and economic growth is difficult to predict. Investors who pay too much attention to electricity as a proxy for growth can misread the signs. This was the case in the first half of 2009, when growth in electricity output stayed in negative territory till May – partly because of a slow recovery in the electricity intensive aluminum sector, but the rebound in the rest of the economy was strong. In the second half of 2011, optimism about the outlook based on June’s strong electricity data may be similarly misplaced. Tom Orlik’s new book Understanding China’s Economic Indicators was released July 12
By Tom Orlik China’s Vice Premier Li Keqiang said in 2007 that the GDP data for the world’s second largest economy was ‘man made’ and not to be trusted. Instead, the then Party Secretary of Liaoning Province said, he relied on electricity production, train freight and bank loan data as a guide to the state of the economy. Last month, CRT looked at the strengths and weaknesses of China’s GDP data, concluding that the government’s methods for calculating the size of the world’s second-largest economy had improved but still left something to be desired . Are electricity statistics a better guide to growth? Electricity output has a special place in the world of China’s economic data. Officials might lie, it is believed, but volts do not. Ever since economists cried foul on the 1998 GDP data, citing the difference between falling growth in production of electricity and stable growth in GDP, the markets have viewed the electricity data as a proxy for overall growth. That makes some sense. The manufacturing and industrial sectors are major consumers of electricity; changes in output should be reflected in changes in electricity production. Over the last several years, growth in electricity output has moved more or less in line with growth in industrial output. With some of China’s main growth indicators putting in a dismal performance in the last few months, and concerns about a hard landing for the economy, the electricity data provides an optimistic counterpoint. Following a weak April and May, electricity output was up 16.2% year-on-year in June, suggesting a strengthening economy. That contrasts with a weak reading from the preliminary HSBC PMI report in July, which suggested contraction is on the cards. But before breaking out the celebratory baijiu and heading out for karaoke, China’s economic policy makers should consider a few shortcomings of the electricity output data as a guide to growth: – Changes in the structure of the economy change the relationship between growth and electricity consumption. For example, a shrinking role for manufacturing and a larger role for services – something China’s economic planners have been pushing lately — reduces growth in electricity production but not necessarily growth in GDP. And even with no change in the structure of industry, many manufacturers have off-grid generators that they can switch on or off without affecting electricity production data – which only captures on-grid activity. – China’s electricity producers have their own problems. Hydropower accounts for 16% of China’s electricity output. Droughts in April and May meant generators ran into difficulties. Heavy rain has now brought them whirring back to life. Neither the drought nor the flood said much about the underlying strength of demand for electricity. Changes in costs for coal – the main input into electricity generation – can also play havoc with production. – Households account for 12% of electricity consumption and their demand is affected mainly by the weather – which determines whether central heating and air conditioners are on or off – with little relation to changes in growth. All of these factors mean the relation between electricity production and economic growth is difficult to predict. Investors who pay too much attention to electricity as a proxy for growth can misread the signs. This was the case in the first half of 2009, when growth in electricity output stayed in negative territory till May – partly because of a slow recovery in the electricity intensive aluminum sector, but the rebound in the rest of the economy was strong. In the second half of 2011, optimism about the outlook based on June’s strong electricity data may be similarly misplaced. Tom Orlik’s new book Understanding China’s Economic Indicators was released July 12
The rest is here:
Volts Don’t Lie? An Alternative Approach to Calculating China’s Growth
Business
China’s Golden Rooster Film Festival Kicks Off in Xiamen – Thailand Business News
The 2024 China Golden Rooster and Hundred Flowers Film Festival began in Xiamen on Nov 13, featuring awards, cultural projects worth 31.63 billion yuan, and fostering international film collaborations.
2024 China Golden Rooster and Hundred Flowers Film Festival Opens
The 2024 China Golden Rooster and Hundred Flowers Film Festival commenced in Xiamen, Fujian province, on November 13. This prestigious event showcases the top film awards in China and spans four days, concluding with the China Golden Rooster Awards ceremony on November 16.
The festival features various film exhibitions, including the Golden Rooster Mainland Film Section and the Golden Rooster International Film Section. These showcases aim to highlight the achievements of Chinese-language films and foster global cultural exchanges within the film industry.
On the festival’s opening day, a significant milestone was reached with the signing of 175 cultural and film projects, valued at 31.63 billion yuan ($4.36 billion). Additionally, the International Film and Television Copyright Service Platform was launched, furthering the globalization of Chinese film and television properties.
Source : China’s Golden Rooster film festival opens in Xiamen – Thailand Business News
China
Italy and China New DTA Set to Take Effect in 2025: Important Changes and Implications
Italy ratified an upgraded Double Tax Agreement (DTA) with China, effective in 2025, to reduce tax burdens, prevent evasion, and enhance investment. The DTA introduces modern provisions aligned with international standards, targeting tax avoidance and improving dispute resolution for Italian businesses.
Italy recently ratified the upgraded Double Tax Agreement (DTA), which will finally take effect in 2025. This agreement was signed in 2019 and was designed to reduce tax burdens, prevent tax evasion, and promote Italian investment in China.
On November 5, 2024, Italy’s Chamber of Deputies gave final approval to the ratification of the 2019 Double Tax Agreement (DTA) between Italy and China (hereinafter, referred to as the “new DTA”).
Set to take effect in 2025, the new DTA is aimed at eliminating double taxation on income, preventing tax evasion, and creating a more favorable environment for Italian businesses operating in China.
The ratification bill for the new DTA consists of four articles, with Article 3 detailing the financial provisions. Starting in 2025, the implementation costs of the agreement are estimated at €10.86 million (US$11.49 million) annually. These costs will be covered by a reduction in the special current expenditure fund allocated in the Italian Ministry of Economy’s 2024 budget, partially drawing from the reserve for the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
During the parliamentary debate, Deputy Foreign Minister Edmondo Cirielli emphasized the new DTA’s strategic importance, noting that the agreement redefines Italy’s economic and financial framework with China. Cirielli highlighted that the DTA not only strengthens relations with the Chinese government but also supports Italian businesses, which face increasing competition as other European countries have already established double taxation agreements with China. This ratification, therefore, is part of a broader series of diplomatic and economic engagements, leading up to a forthcoming visit by the President of the Italian Republic to China, underscoring Italy’s commitment to fostering bilateral relations and supporting its businesses in China’s complex market landscape.
The newly signed DTA between Italy and China, introduces several modernized provisions aligned with international tax frameworks. Replacing the 1986 DTA, the agreement adopts measures from the OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Project and the OECD Multilateral Instrument (MLI), targeting tax avoidance and improving dispute resolution.
The Principal Purpose Test (PPT) clause, inspired by BEPS, is one of the central updates in the new DTA, working to prevent treaty abuse. This clause allows tax benefits to be denied if one of the primary purposes of a transaction or arrangement was to gain a tax advantage, a move to counter tax evasion through treaty-shopping.
| This article was first published by China Briefing , which is produced by Dezan Shira & Associates. The firm assists foreign investors throughout Asia from offices across the world, including in in China, Hong Kong, Vietnam, Singapore, and India . Readers may write to info@dezshira.com for more support. |
Read the rest of the original article.
Business
China’s New Home Prices Stabilize After 17-Month Decline Following Support Measures
China’s new home prices fell for the 17th month in October, declining 0.5% from September, but slowing, indicating potential market stabilization amid supportive measures. Second-hand home prices showed mixed trends.
Decline in China’s Home Prices Stabilizes
China’s new home prices continued to decline in October for the 17th consecutive month, although the drop showed signs of slowing. Recent support measures from Beijing appear to be inching the market toward stabilization, as evidenced by a lighter decline compared to earlier months.
Monthly and Yearly Comparisons
According to the latest data from the National Bureau of Statistics, new home prices across 70 mainland cities fell by 0.5% from September, marking the smallest decrease in seven months. Year-on-year, prices dropped by 6.2%, slightly worse than the September decline of 6.1%. In tier-1 cities like Beijing and Shanghai, prices decreased by 0.2%, a smaller fall than 0.5% in the previous month.
Second-Hand Home Market Trends
Second-hand home prices in tier-1 cities experienced a 0.4% increase in October, reversing a 13-month downward trend. Conversely, tier-2 cities observed a 0.4% drop in second-hand prices, while tier-3 cities faced a similar 0.5% decline. Overall, recent trends indicate a potential stabilization in China’s property market.
Source : China’s new home prices slow 17-month decline after support measures kick in
- China’s Golden Rooster Film Festival Kicks Off in Xiamen – Thailand Business News
- Italy and China New DTA Set to Take Effect in 2025: Important Changes and Implications
- China’s New Home Prices Stabilize After 17-Month Decline Following Support Measures
- U.S. national debt is its Achilles’ heel, but China sees it as an opportunity
- Business Update: Southern Sun Reports Earnings Growth; China Stimulates Property Market – News24
- Vietnam’s Approach to China: A Balance of Cooperation and Struggle